If you're looking for a lighthearted, humorous series with a focus on character development, Toilet no Hanakosan may be the better choice. However, if you prefer a darker, more action-oriented series with a richly detailed world, Kukkyou Taimashi is the way to go.
Ultimately, the choice between these two series depends on the reader's or viewer's preferences. Both "Toilet no Hanakosan" and "Kukkyou Taimashi" have their merits, offering distinct experiences that cater to a wide range of interests within the manga and anime community.
Over decades, Hanako-san has evolved. Early versions (1950s-70s) depicted her as a friendly ghost who would give you toilet paper. Post-1990s, influenced by the J-horror boom, she became malicious. Common variations include:
In Kukkyou Taimashi , the ghosts are often obstacles, but the true "deep" theme is the protagonist's social alienation. He is a "Kukkyou" (a strong, stalwart, but solitary figure). The ghosts are often manifestations of negative human emotions that he must physically punch away. The narrative argues that monsters are not always the scary ones ; often, the scary ones are the judgmental humans looking at the exorcist.